Personal Financial Advisor to Founders, Entrepreneurs, and their Families | Keystone Global Partners
For many people, real estate has been their best investment. However, stocks have actually been far better at generating long-term returns for investors, as seen by comparing the returns of the S&P 500 and the S&P/Case-Shiller home price index since 1990. Why is there such a disconnect?
Misconceptions On Real Estate Returns
Peeling back the layers reveals some of the key factors that make real estate seem like the better investment:
• Immense use of leverage: No other common investments will allow an investor to take on the same level of debt to make an investment. Mortgages allow 5-1 leverage with a 20% down payment and even higher levels of leverage when using smaller down payments. The leverage magnifies even small gains in the property value, but remember, it can cut both ways if the property value declines.
• Illiquidity prevents human error: Real estate transactions have high costs and take significant effort. This is usually enough to deter investors from making hasty, panic-induced decisions during market volatility. Poor decisions are more prevalent in the stock market, where selling investments can happen in seconds with no material transaction costs.
Real estate also receives tax benefits from capital gain exclusions on primary homes to rental depreciation on investment real estate; however, this is somewhat offset by holding property tax costs, which stocks do not incur.
Converting A Primary Residence To An Investment Property
When moving on to a new house, some individuals decide to convert their original home into a rental property that becomes an income source.
You can convert your primary residence into a rental property by making a few smart moves. You start by determining your property’s tax basis to calculate depreciation during the rental period. When you eventually sell, this will factor into gain/loss calculations. The conversion date varies in your favor based on whether there was a gain or a loss.
Once you’ve converted your home into a rental property, you must adhere to landlords’ tax rules, but with that, you will gain a number of favorable benefits. You can deduct real estate taxes and mortgage interest on a rental property, and you do not have to pay self-employment tax on landlord income. You can write off your operating expenses, such as maintenance and repairs, association fees, utilities, and lawn care. You can also depreciate the cost of the property over 27.5 years, even if the value increases. This depreciation can offset a significant portion of your rental property income, which translates to low taxes on this income stream. You may run into issues if you have a tax loss, but you should be able to offset this over time with increasing rents. When you sell the investment property, you can use a 1031 exchange and defer taxes if you “swap” the property with another investment property of like kind and equal or greater value.
It is also important to carefully weigh the costs of being a landlord. To start, rent must cover all carrying costs because you certainly do not want an asset to cost you money. Also, you need to make an allowance for unexpected periods where you might not have a tenant and have to float the carrying costs out of pocket. A mistake you often hear of is an investor who overleveraged and owned 10 houses and then had to sell them all at a loss in a downturn. Perhaps more importantly, you should never ignore the qualitative question of whether you want to be a landlord. It can be time-consuming and even take an emotional toll on you as you worry about the property or your tenants. Not everyone wants to deal with late rent payments, requests to fix bathrooms and leaky ceilings, or property damage caused by untrustworthy tenants.
This four-part series covered answers to many of the questions that come up when our tech founder clients consider a real estate purchase.
Part 1 offered founders a framework to decide whether renting or buying is the right choice. Part 2 explored how a home purchase could potentially fit into your overall financial plan. Part 3 discussed real estate financing options, taking into account the entire process, including risk, taxes, cost savings, profit and legalities. And Part 4 dove into the topic of real estate as a financial asset, examining common misconceptions and opportunities.
This concludes the series. I hope you find this information helpful as you think through your real estate decisions and navigate your next steps.
The information provided here is not investment, tax or financial advice. You should consult with a licensed professional for advice concerning your specific situation.
Forbes Finance Council is an invitation-only organization for executives in successful accounting, financial planning and wealth management firms. Do I qualify?
Personal Financial Advisor to Founders, Entrepreneurs, and their Families | Keystone Global Partners. Read Peyton Carr’s full executive profile here.